Loading... Please wait...

Our Newsletter

1lb bar Super Super Extra Sharp Cheddar Cheese

Or Specify a Delivery Date:

(Maximum Size: . Type: )
Gift Message:

The perfect size block for those of you that want to have this delicious cheese for yourself. The family members and employees are always looking for pieces of this cheese when we cut a block. You can not get any better a review than those who are closest to you.

Find Similar Products by Category

Write your own product review

Product Reviews

Showing reviews 1-10 of 19 | Next

  1. 96 month aged crystals 5 Star Review

    Posted by on 29th Sep 2018

    The crystals that have aged for eight years and explode in the mouth are evident in this outstanding cheddar. I’ve purchased in both 2014 and 2017 and the consistency between the years is flawless. Sugarbush Farm has mastered aging cheese in addition to producing second to none maple syrup. This 96 month aged cheddar is a bargain!

  2. Holy Grail of cheddar 5 Star Review

    Posted by on 28th Sep 2018

    This stuff is the Holy Grail of cheddar. Another brand, (won't mention their name here) of "significantly sharp" cheddar can't even hold a candle to this cheese. Has the amazing flavor crystals that serious cheeseheads know and love. Forget trying to slice, this just crumbles. Almost too good to waste on cheese and crackers. If there is a better cheddar available, I haven't found it.

  3. Old Cheese 5 Star Review

    Posted by on 15th Jun 2018

    This cheese is terrible!! I recommend that anyone who has purchased this cheese to send their remaining cheese to me for proper disposal!
    Thanks and I will see to it this cheese disappears!

  4. Best. Cheddar. Anywhere. (Shhh) 5 Star Review

    Posted by on 12th Jan 2018

    I am approach-avoidant about writing this review. On the one hand, this is - hands down - the best and sharpest cheddar I've ever had. We first discovered it at the farm about a decade ago and have consistently ordered it since. Try as we might, can't find anything close. It crumbles in the way you want, and we usually don't insult it by adding a cracker. It doesn't need it! The avoidant part? I know there are limited quantities and want to always be able to get our fix! Really, this is the best sharp cheddar available as far as I'm aware, at an amazing price given the quality.

  5. Better than 12 year old Wisconsin Cheeses 5 Star Review

    Posted by on 8th Jan 2018

    We have been a fan of the 8 year aged cheddar for many years. It has a sharpness and slight crustyness that can not be matched. We send it to our closest friends as gifts and they always want more. This summer we were in Wisconsin and sampled numberous aged cheddar cheeses. Not even the 12 year old cheeses could compare to the quality of this cheese.

  6. A tremendous aged cheddar! 5 Star Review

    Posted by on 28th Dec 2017

    Always love ordering and receiving Sugarbush Farms cheese! Also love the fact that they lay back and age some of their cheddars - this almost 8 year old cheddar is excellent!

  7. There is none better 5 Star Review

    Posted by on 4th Dec 2017

    This cheese is the ne plus ultra of cheddar. C***t Extra-Sharp doesn't even come close. When I put this out at my holiday parties, my guests always ask if it's the "Holy Grail" cheese. Crumbly, with tons of the flavor crystals that only come from long aging, this is a cheese for savoring. It's almost too good for crackers! Makes a great gift for friends too! I discovered Sugarbush Farms cheese at a country store in Queechee back in the early 2000s and I've been going back to the farm several times a year to get my cheese fix ever since.

  8. The Best 5 Star Review

    Posted by on 12th Mar 2017


  9. Best Cheese Ever 5 Star Review

    Posted by on 28th Dec 2016

    I love this cheese and order it every Christmas for my favorite people. Sharp and delicious, it perfectly relates holiday cheer.

  10. Simply the Best 5 Star Review

    Posted by on 22nd Dec 2016

    I used to travel up to Pico every year with friends. In my travels to the area I stumbled upon Sugarbush Farms. I fell in love with your products. I took my whole family once, and my oldest daughter just couldn't get enough of the 8 year old cheddar, and my son loved the maple syrup, so every Christmas I make sure Santa delivers what they want. Strange, but after a few visits, you feel a part of the Sugarbush family.

Showing reviews 1-10 of 19 | Next

You Recently Viewed...