Loading... Please wait...

Our Newsletter


For those of you who can't find cheese sharp enough...wait until you try our 11 year old Super Super Extra Sharp with some of those crunchy protein crystals some folks love.  We only have a limited amount.

8oz 11 year old Super Super Extra Sharp Cheddar Cheese

Your Price:
$16.50 (You save $1.00)

Write your own product review

Product Reviews

  1. worth the price 5 Star Review

    Posted by on 1st Apr 2017

    We hesitated to spend this much on a half-pound of cheese, but having enjoyed Sugarbush Farm cheese for many years, convinced us to give it a try. We are so glad that we did, extremely sharp with a multitude of the crunchy little flavor crystals that mark a true aged cheddar. Absolutely awesome. Thanks Betsy and family.

  2. Best cheddar 5 Star Review

    Posted by on 14th Mar 2017

    This is the best cheddar I've had so far...

    I try to get the oldest cheddar you offer each year, you sure offer exceptional cheese every year. Your going to have a tough time out doing it next year!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  3. always excellent 5 Star Review

    Posted by on 23rd Feb 2017

    my wife and I are frequent visitors to the farm when we're in Vermont and I must admit that when we get notified of these specially aged cheddars we are online immediately to order. we even buy extras for my parents who love the texture and the little crystals. sooo good.

  4. Heaven 5 Star Review

    Posted by on 16th Feb 2017

    I love cheddar but this is incredible. It is so good, it is only used for special celebrations and is in a vacuumed sealed bag in the fridge otherwise. I love Sugarbush anyway but this was the best!

  5. Sharp -n- Good 5 Star Review

    Posted by on 16th Feb 2017

    I really enjoy the Extra Sharp Cheddar cheeses, and this one is the best I have found! Minimal crystalline content with excellent room temperature flavor. This is a cheese to be enjoyed by itself, no cracker needed or wanted. A sip of your favorite wine and the experience is complete. Not your everyday cheese.

  6. Cheese from Sugarbush Farm is the Best 5 Star Review

    Posted by on 27th Jul 2016

    Hi Sugarbush Farm family,
    My husband Robert and daughter and future son-in-law, Elizabeth and Ian LOVE YOUR CHEESE. I do not eat cheese........but I love your maple syrup....have a great day

  7. Can't beat it! 5 Star Review

    Posted by on 12th Jul 2016

    Awesome cheese if you like real sharp cheese be sure to try this one! One of my favorites..
    Thank you Sugarbish :-)

  8. The best chedder ever! 5 Star Review

    Posted by on 17th Mar 2015

    I split my order with a friend and he said it was better than sex! I'd say it was awesome.

  9. No Words Can Describe It 5 Star Review

    Posted by on 12th Mar 2015

    Absolutely the best aged cheddar I've had. Has the just the right "bite". I got so carried away with this cheese, I finished the block in two days!

You Recently Viewed...