Loading... Please wait...

Our Newsletter


8 years old

******During the hot summer months we suggest adding the insulated box to your order******

5lb Super Super Extra Sharp Cheddar Cheese


Write your own product review

Product Reviews

  1. Magnificent 8-year-old White Cheddar 5 Star Review

    Posted by on 30th Dec 2016

    This cheddar, at 8 years old, has the flavor, texture, aroma and body of a cheddar at least 3-4 years older. Not only is this the finest 8-year cheddar that I have ever tasted, the price placed it almost into the "bargain" category. What more could anyone ask?

  2. "TRUE" Extra Sharp Cheddar 5 Star Review

    Posted by on 24th Apr 2015

    Reminds me of Canadian Black Diamond USED to be like; you will not be disappointed!

  3. Best Ever! 5 Star Review

    Posted by on 25th Dec 2014

    I can't get enough of it!

  4. Best Sharp Cheddar Ever 5 Star Review

    Posted by on 1st Dec 2014

    I love a good extra sharp cheddar, and have tried many different ones over the years. The Sugarbush 8 year old is the best I've ever had -- bar none. It is tangy and sharp, yet has a somewhat buttery texture. Can't praise it highly enough.

  5. Full of Flavor 5 Star Review

    Posted by on 4th Oct 2014

    Best sharp cheddar I have ate. This cheese explodes with sharp cheddar taste.

  6. I am lactose intolerant...... 5 Star Review

    Posted by on 4th Oct 2014

    THIS IS THE ONLY CHEESE THAT I HAVE BEEN ABLE TO TOLERATE IN 3 YEARS..I visited the shop and trusted the info I received. IT IS AMAZING TO BE ABLE TO EAT CHEESE AGAIN, I love it!

  7. best ever 5 Star Review

    Posted by on 4th Aug 2014

    This cheese is the best sharp cheddar I have had in my 50+ years of enjoying good cheeses.

  8. Can't Praise It Enough 5 Star Review

    Posted by on 11th May 2014

    I first tried it last September on a visit to the Farm. I've ordered it several times since then -- it is expensive, but it is also, without a doubt, the very best sharp cheddar I have ever tasted.

  9. The Best Cheese 5 Star Review

    Posted by on 5th Dec 2013

    I love cheese, Love to cook with it. Love to eat it. I've been buying great cheese from Sugarbush for years and I've never been disappointed.

  10. Amazing 5 Star Review

    Posted by on 16th Sep 2013

    This "old"cheese is amazing. The flavor is, by far, the best flavor in a cheese I have ever had during my 68 years of cheesing. It is expensive, but understandable since they need to keep it under exact conditions for a long time. If you love true favor in the cheese, try this.

You Recently Viewed...